Some Places More Than Others

Some Places More Than Others by Renee Watson is a realistic fiction novel about a little girl's journey to learn more about her family, and in turn, herself.  The novel is 191 pages, so it is a great "faster" read for readers who may shy away from longer books.  While the story is very relatable for kids entering their teenager years and looking for approval and to be considered as more responsible (with more freedoms) by their parents, this novel also dives deep into African American history.  Amara is FINALLY able to visit New York City, the birthplace of the Harlem Renaissance, and learns just as much about her heritage as she does her own family.  

In a few short weeks Amara will be 12, and she will also be a big sister for the first time.  The only thing she wants for her birthday is the same thing she has been begging her parents for for years - a trip to New York City.  Amara wants to meet her extended family there - her grandfather, aunt, and cousins she has only heard about and seen pictures of at this point. Amara lives in Oregon with her father and mother, who are finally expecting a baby girl. Her father works for Nike and has an upcoming work trip to New York City, and Amara knows this is her last chance to visit her family.  But her parents still refuse.  Then Amara finds her chance: the Suitcase Project that has been assigned by her teacher Mr. Rosen.  Each student will create a time capsule of their family that explores the family's past, present, and future.  Amara sees this as her chance!  She pleads with her parents, promoting the trip in the name of school, and they finally give in!  Amara is able to travel with her father to meet her relatives and see the wonders of the iconic New York City.  But Amara's trip isn't everything she thought it would be.  She quickly learns there is a reason she has not made the trip before and the relationship between her father and grandfather was severed years ago. Amara makes the trip to learn more about the family she has heard about and complete her school project, but ends up learning more than she ever thought possible about people, relationships, and her rich African American history in walking the streets of Harlem.  

Some Places More Than Others by Renee Watson is a great book for upper elementary or middle school readers.  I would expect girls may enjoy this novel more than boys since the narrator is female.  While this novel is not packed with action and adventure, it is packed with love and struggle and forgiveness.  I also recommend this novel for readers in cities with big history.  Amara is mesmerized by the sights and rich history of Harlem's streets, but Amara's cousins are jaded by it, not understanding her fascination.  As a resident of Birmingham, it reminded me of my own city's rich history that I often take for granted.  This novel was a great reminder not to forget the people and places that make our city unique with memories to be preserved and not forgotten, no matter how often they are seen.  Amara's passion to know more about her heritage and family is inspiring.  She is a beautiful character with a genuine heart that will certainly stick with readers.